Times Jumbo Cryptic Crossword 1598

Run to the hills, people! The French Elder Gods will be most displeased this week, the setter having the temerity to entirely neglect their duties in shoehorning at least one French reference into this week’s Jumbo. Mon dieu!

Mock Francophobic silliness aside, as if you need telling, this week’s Jumbo was a stinker. I suspect this setter’s previous Jumbo was one I accused of being artificially difficult through being overly filled with lazy made-to-fit trash, so it’s good to see a marked reduction this time around. The quality of construction in the clues was also mostly excellent, though there were a few areas where setter and solver weren’t on the same page. It’s just a shame it was such a 52d to complete. It’s weird as I do love misdirection, the more convoluted clues, and clues that have me camped out in my dictionaries, but this started to outstay its welcome by the end. Be careful of what you wish for, I guess.

Anyway, you can find my completed grid below along with explanations of my solutions where I have them. I hope you find them helpful, though it might be worth checking back in case more info comes to light in the comments. Meanwhile, if a recent Jumbo has you pulling your hair out then you might find my Just For Fun page of use, where you’ll find links to solutions for hundreds of the things.

Thanks again for the kind words and input. It’s always interesting to hear the thoughts of solvers once the dust has settled. Till next time, stay safe out there kids.


[With thanks to Sue and Chris in the comments for fixing 48d.]

Across clues

  1. Very young private in film hugging married soldier (11)

Answer: INFANTRYMAN (i.e. “soldier”). Solution is INFANT (i.e. “very young”) followed by RYAN (i.e. “private in film”, referring to the 1998 movie Saving Private Ryan) once wrapped around or “hugging” M (a recognised abbreviation of “married”), like so: INFANT-RY(M)AN.

  1. A number to be received by Granma? (2,4,5)

Answer: GO DOWN MOSES (i.e. “a number” or song). Solution is GO DOWN (i.e. “be received”, say, by an audience) followed by “Granma” MOSES, an American folk artist. Although pretty much every reference I’ve seen describes her as “Grandma”, not “Granma”. Could be a typo; could be the setter dicking around.

  1. Old bits of logbook laid out oddly (5)

Answer: OBOLI (i.e. “old bits” – over to Chambers: “in ancient Greece, the sixth part of a drachma in weight or in money”). “Oddly” indicates the solution is found in every other letter of LOGBOOK LAID. I guess “out” is there just to make the clue scan. The wordplay was mercifully obvious but, let’s be honest, this was a made-to-fit solution any day of the week.

  1. One guilty of slowing down after initially leading in competition (7)

Answer: CULPRIT (i.e. “one guilty”). Solution is RIT (i.e. “slowing down”, specifically a recognised abbreviation of ritardando in musical lingo) placed “after” L (i.e. “initially leading”, i.e. the first letter of “leading”) once this has been placed “in” CUP (i.e. “competition”), like so: (CU(L)P)-RIT.

  1. One is going to a kid experiencing discomfort (3,2,4)

Answer: ILL AT EASE (i.e. “experiencing discomfort”). Solution is I’LL (i.e. “one is going to”, specifically a contraction of I WILL) followed by A, then TEASE (i.e. to “kid”).

  1. Accompanying racing driver, holding maximum speed in relentless pursuit (5,4)

Answer: WITCH HUNT (i.e. “relentless pursuit”). Solution is WITH (i.e. “accompanying”) and James HUNT (i.e. “racing driver” and 1976 F1 champion) all wrapped around or “holding” C (i.e. “maximum speed”, specifically a constant in physics representing the speed of light, the C in Einstein’s famous equation E=mc2), like so: WIT(C)H-HUNT.

  1. Pacifying English gangster’s girl, one so uninitiated (10)

Answer: EMOLLIENCE (i.e. “pacifying”). Solution is E (a recognised abbreviation of “English”) followed by MOLL (i.e. “gangster’s girl”), then I (i.e. “[Roman numeral] one”) and HENCE (i.e. “so”) once its first letter has been removed (indicated by “uninitiated”), like so: E-MOLL-I-ENCE.

  1. Wound, not quite septic, that finally is to return again (2-5)

Answer: RE-ELECT (i.e. “to return again” – think returning officers in elections). Solution is REELED (i.e. to have spun or “wound”) once its last letter has been removed (indicated by “not quite”) and the remainder followed by C and T (i.e. “septic, that finally”, i.e. the last letters of “septic” and “that”), like so: REELE-CT.

  1. Set of possible caravanserai pictures brought back (7)

Answer: TRANNIE (i.e. “set”, or transistor radio). I’m not 100% sure on this one, but I’ve got INN (i.e. “caravanserai”, an old inn in some Eastern countries) and ART (i.e. “pictures”) all reversed (indicated by “brought back”). That gives me TRA-NNI. I guess the E comes from “possible” somehow. Maybe a “finally” indicator was lost in the edit?

[EDIT: Thanks to Sue in the comments for suggesting INN is more likely to have been E INN in the solution, given caravanserai were inns in some Eastern countries. That should then give you the missing E. Cheers, Sue! – LP]

  1. Resort after a time has spread to west and east (7)

Answer: MARGATE (i.e. “resort” or coastal town in Kent). Solution is A and T (a recognised abbreviation of “time”) placed in or having “to west and east” of it MARGE (i.e. “spread” or margarine), like so: MARG(A-T)E.

  1. On a motorway it can be hard to bear (8)

Answer: SHOULDER. Solution satisfies “on a motorway it can be hard” and “to bear”.

  1. Maybe be prone to risk neck, somehow, with hesitation (5,2,4,3)

Answer: SKATE ON THIN ICE (i.e. “maybe be prone to risk”). Solution is an anagram (indicated by “somehow”) of NECK and HESITATION.

  1. Ancient writer’s revolutionary main work (5)

Answer: AESOP (i.e. “ancient writer”). Solution is SEA (i.e. “main” – one definition is the high sea) and OP (i.e. “work”, specifically a recognised abbreviation of “opus”) each reversed (indicated by “revolutionary”), like so: AES-OP.

  1. Not needing to diet, presumably, one consumes a sort of dip? (6)

Answer: TAHINI (i.e. “sort of dip”, specifically “an oily paste made of crushed sesame seeds” (Chambers)). Solution is THIN (i.e. “not needing to diet, presumably”) and I (i.e. “[Roman numeral] one”) all wrapped around or “consuming” A, like so: T(A)HIN-I. Did you pencil in SKINNY to begin with? Me too.

  1. A U category changed to appeal to immature adult? (3,4,3)

Answer: ACT YOUR AGE (i.e. “appeal to immature adult”). “Changed” indicates anagram. Solution is an anagram of A U CATEGORY.

  1. Note left in hotel on an American battlefield (10)

Answer: AUSTERLITZ (i.e. a “battlefield” of the Napoleonic wars). Solution is TE (i.e. musical “note” of the sol-fa scale) followed by L (a recognised abbreviation of “left”) once placed “in” RITZ (a “hotel” chain). This is all then placed “on” or after A US (i.e. “an American”), like so: (A-US)-(TE-R(L)ITZ). Chalk one to my Bradford’s here. I’d reached the “I really can’t be arsed” point.

  1. Soap possibly put outside because full of cracks? (6)

Answer: JOCOSE (i.e. “full or cracks” or jokes). Solution is JOE (i.e. “Soap possibly”, referring to Joe Soap, rhyming slang for a dope) placed “outside” of COS (an informal shortened form of “because”), like so: JO(COS)E.

  1. One running paper chases hit and disabled (5)

Answer: LAMED (i.e. “disabled”). Solution is ED (i.e. “one running paper”, short for editor) placed after or “chasing” LAM (i.e. to “hit”), like so: LAM-ED.

  1. Offence at Rugby which Dr Arnold was there to stop (5,2,3,4)

Answer: KNOCK ON THE HEAD (i.e. “stop”). Solution is KNOCK ON (i.e. “offence at rugby”, ignoring the misleading capitalisation) followed by THE HEAD (i.e. “Dr [Thomas] Arnold”, who was a reforming headmaster of Rugby School in the 1800s). Nicely worked.

  1. Buy drinks all round for Americans? Suffers in the morning! (5,3)

Answer: STAND SAM (i.e. “buy drinks all round for Americans” – none of my formal dictionaries back this up, which is disappointing, but it does get a mention in my Cassell’s Dictionary of Slang). Solution is STANDS (i.e. ensures or “suffers”) followed by AM (i.e. “in the morning”).

  1. One adding to musical score maybe, unlike one appearing at Glastonbury? (7)

Answer: NOTATOR (i.e. “one adding to musical score maybe”). When written as NOT A TOR the solution also playfully satisfies “unlike one appearing at Glastonbury” – St Michael’s Tower that sits atop Glastonbury Tor often gets photographed against blood moons, super moons etc.

  1. Eliminate any reason to make a face when speaking (4,3)

Answer: WIPE OUT (i.e. “eliminate”). Solution comprises homophones (indicated by “when speaking”) of WHY (i.e. “any reason” when asked as a question) and POUT (i.e. “make a face”).

  1. Matter that’s collected from a female science graduate, as it were (7)

Answer: ABSCESS (i.e. pus or “matter that’s collected”). The remainder of the clue plays on a jokey “female” form of a BSc or Bachelor of Science (i.e. “science graduate”) by sticking an -ESS on the end, like so: A-BSCESS.

  1. Grand entertainer to direct on-line thriller? (5,5)

Answer: GHOST TRAIN (i.e. “on-line thriller”, referring to the track said attraction runs along). Solution is G (a recognised abbreviation of “grand”) followed by HOST (i.e. “entertainer”) and TRAIN (i.e. “to direct”).

  1. Female longing to return in vain in suit to EastEnders? (9)

Answer: COCKNEYFY (i.e. to “suit to EastEnders” – stick a gold chain and sheepskin coat on it, that kind of thing). Solution is F (a recognised abbreviation of “female”) and YEN (i.e. “longing”) all reversed (indicated by “to return”) and placed “in” COCKY (i.e. “vain”), like so: COCK(NEY-F)Y. I’ll admit to a feeling of mild horror when I found this was an actual word. It’s as if at some point in time cockneyfying was all the rage, sufficient to see it recognised in dictionaries. Gorblimey, that’s chilling.

  1. Article given in love that behold’s removed from wraps? (9)

Answer: VALENTINE. The solution satisfies the waffly clue as a whole, given one would “unwrap” a valentines present or card or some such. Or so I’m told, anyway. I’ve never really understood the point of it all. Meanwhile, it also comprises A (i.e. “article”, being a word like a, an or the), LENT (i.e. “given”) and IN all placed in or “wrapped” by LOVE once the LO (i.e. “behold”) has been “removed”, like so: V(A-LENT-IN)E. Nicely done. Took a while to twig.

  1. Shed on field is to go first (4,3)

Answer: LEAD OFF (i.e. “go first”). Solution is DOFF (i.e. to “shed”) placed “on” or after LEA (a meadow or “field”), like so: LEA-DOFF.

  1. Pirate copy ultimately you can’t play at school! (8)

Answer: HOOKY (i.e. truancy or something “you can’t play at school”). Solution is HOOK (i.e. “pirate” captain, Peter Pan’s adversary) followed by Y (i.e. “copy ultimately”, i.e. the last letter of “copy”).

  1. Deception in the book-keeping department maybe picked up by auditors (11)

Answer: LEGERDEMAIN (i.e. “deception”). Solution comprises homophones (indicated by “picked up by auditors”) of LEDGER DOMAIN (i.e. “book-keeping department”).

  1. After winding up down there, rueful in the extreme? (6,5)

Answer: NETHER WORLD. The solution satisfies the clue as a whole, being another way to describe hell, but is also formed through an anagram (indicated by “winding up”) of DOWN THERE and RL (i.e. “rueful in the extreme”, i.e. the first and last letters of “rueful”).

Down clues

  1. Implication one can go ahead and press for casting location? (9)

Answer: IRONWORKS (i.e. “casting location”). When written as IRON WORKS the solution also satisfies “implication one can go ahead and press” clothes.

  1. Thus draw a bit perhaps on good authority… (4,3,6,5)

Answer: FROM THE HORSE’S MOUTH. Solution satisfies “thus draw a bit perhaps” – a bit being an item of riding gear – and “on good authority”.

  1. …as this comes reportedly indeed (5)

Answer: NEIGH (i.e. “as this comes”, following on from the previous solution, being the noise a horse makes). “Reportedly” indicates homophone. Solution is a homophone of NAY (i.e. “indeed”).

  1. Park game, one people entering races find engaging (11)

Answer: RECRUITMENT (i.e. the act of “engaging” personnel). Solution is REC (i.e. “park” or recreation area) followed by RU (i.e. “game”, specifically Rugby Union), then I (i.e. “[Roman numeral] one”), then MEN (i.e. “people” – well, 48% of them anyway) once placed in or “entering” TT (i.e. motorbike “races” held on the Isle of Man), like so: REC-RU-I-T(MEN)T.

  1. A title one translated at the end of William Tell? (8)

Answer: MILITATE (i.e. to “tell” against – ignore the misleading capitalisation). Solution is an anagram (indicated by “translated”) of A TITLE and I (i.e. “[Roman numeral] one”, again again again) all placed after or “at the end of” M (i.e. “end [letter] of William” – a bit of recycling there), like so: M-ILITATE.

  1. Trying bottle on shelf with iodine: no good (5-7)

Answer: NERVE-RACKING (i.e. an ordeal or “trying”). Solution is NERVE (i.e. “bottle”) followed by RACK (i.e. “shelf”), then I (chemical symbol of “iodine”), then N (a recognised abbreviation of “no”) and G (ditto “good”).

  1. Persuade couple over the phone to make do, finally (3,5,2)

Answer: GET ROUND TO (i.e. “do, finally”). Solution is GET ROUND (i.e. “persuade”) followed by a homophone (indicated by “over the phone”) of TWO (i.e. “couple”).

  1. “Physician heal thyself!” we might thus infer is the instruction (5)

Answer: DRILL (i.e. “instruction”, as in a military drill). When written as DR ILL the solution playfully satisfies “’Physician heal thyself!’ we might thus infer”, DR being a recognised abbreviation of a doctor or “physician”.

  1. Comic about to change male fantasy character (6,5)

Answer: WALTER MITTY (i.e. “fantasy character” from James Thurber’s short story The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty, in which the titular character imagines himself in a variety of heroic scenarios). Solution is WITTY (i.e. “comic”) wrapped “about” ALTER (i.e. “to change”) and M (a recognised abbreviation of “male”), like so: W(ALTER-M)ITTY.

  1. Faced fine for burying fish bones (9)

Answer: METACARPI (i.e. “bones” found between the wrist and fingers). Solution is MET (i.e. “faced”) and AI (i.e. “fine”, excellent or A1 written with the 1 replaced by its Roman numeral equivalent) once wrapped around or “burying” CARP (i.e. “fish”), like so: MET-A(CARP)I.

  1. Special effects seen after consuming a port! (4)

Answer: SFAX (i.e. “port” of Tunisia). Solution is SFX (short for “special effects”) wrapped around or “consuming” A, like so: SF(A)X. The wordplay was mercifully obvious but consider for a moment how many words also fit the letters “S-A-“. You know, actual real everyday words. Ugh. Come off it, setter.

  1. Horse-drawn vehicle, often small and light (4)

Answer: SLED (i.e. “horse-drawn vehicle, often”). Solution is S (a recognised abbreviation of “small”) followed by LED (i.e. “light”, specifically a Light Emitting Diode).

  1. Battered car (Golf) multistorey may track and film (7,7,4)

Answer: MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR (i.e. “track and film” by The Beatles). Solution is an anagram (indicated by “battered”) of CAR, G (“Golf” in the phonetic alphabet) and MULITSTOREY MAY. Nicely worked.

  1. Vicar – the first lady – meeting resistance: split follows (8)

Answer: REVEREND (i.e. “vicar”). Solution is EVE (i.e. “the first lady” in The Bible) placed after or “meeting” R (a recognised abbreviation of electrical “resistance”) and “followed” by REND (i.e. “split”), like so: (R-EVE)-REND.

  1. Edge, if not round … is this maybe? (7)

Answer: ELLIPSE. The solution fits the clue as a whole, but also comprises LIP (i.e. “edge”) with ELSE (i.e. “if not”) wrapped “round” it, like so: EL(LIP)SE. Another nicely worked clue that took a while to twig.

  1. Schoolboy class of 2021 for example? A cut above? (4,4)

Answer: ETON CROP (i.e. “a cut above”, referring to a haircut). The clue also satisfies “schoolboy class of 2021 for example”, though I can’t see why the setter picked out a specific year. Seems an unnecessary attempt to throw the solver.

  1. Doctor Who after hour interrupts musical programme (4,4)

Answer: CHAT SHOW (i.e. “programme”). Solution is an anagram (indicated by “doctor”) of WHO – ignoring the misleading formatting – placed “after” H (a recognised abbreviation of “hour”) once placed in or “interrupting” CATS (i.e. Andrew Lloyd Webber “musical”), like so: C(H)ATS-HOW.

  1. Those from one state sorry to say when leaving another (8)

Answer: ALASKANS (i.e. “those from one [US] state”). Solution is ALAS (i.e. “sorry to say”) followed by KANSAS (i.e. “another” US state) once the AS has been removed (indicated by “when leaving”, AS being another word for “when”), like so: ALAS-KANS.

  1. Completed course in satellite communications (7)

Answer: UPLINKS (i.e. “satellite communications”). Solution is UP (i.e. “completed” or over) followed by LINKS (i.e. golf “course”).

  1. Drinks dispenser is found at an oasis as one’s leaving, sadly (4,8)

Answer: SODA FOUNTAIN (i.e. “drinks dispenser”). Solution is an anagram (indicated by “sadly”) of IS FOUND AT AN OASIS once the AS I’S has been removed (indicated by “as [Roman numeral] one’s leaving”).

  1. Note the employing of an informer somewhere south of Glasgow (11)

Answer: LANARKSHIRE (i.e. “somewhere south of Glasgow”, along with most places if we’re splitting hairs). Solution is LA (i.e. musical “note” in the sol-fa scale) followed by NARK’S HIRE (i.e. “the employing of an informer”).

  1. One on settlement admits transport bases cut (8,3)

Answer: ENTRANCE FEE (i.e. “one on settlement admits”). Solution is ENTRANCE (i.e. to elate or “transport”) followed by FEES (i.e. “bases” – Chambers has this for a base fee: “qualified fee, a freehold estate of inheritance to which a qualification is annexed”, or, in English, an interest in property that is recognised so long as a condition continues to be met) once its last letter has been removed (indicated by “cut”).

[EDIT: Chris in the comments has a better take on “bases cut”, being the word FEET with the last letter removed. Cheers, Chris! – LP]

  1. Blue bloke like a scarlet woman? (10)

Answer: CHAPFALLEN (i.e. “blue”. Can also be spelled CHOPFALLEN, meaning to leave one open-mouthed or dejected). Solution is CHAP (i.e. “bloke”) followed by FALLEN (i.e. “like a scarlet woman” or descriptive of a prostitute).

  1. Nick three fragments to make famous figure in 4 (9)

Answer: Herbert KITCHENER, he of the “Your Country Needs You” posters of the First World War (referenced in “famous figure in 4”, the solution to 4 down being RECRUITMENT). “Fragments” indicates anagram. Solution is an anagram of NICK THREE.

  1. One’s recalled painful swelling you had, on the verge of tears? (5-4)

Answer: MISTY-EYED (i.e. “on the verge of tears”). Solution is I’M (i.e. “one’s” – a contraction of “one is” or I AM) reversed (indicated by “recalled”) followed by STYE (a “painful swelling” of the eye) and YE’D (i.e. a contraction of “you had” – a ye olde indicator like “once” would have been nice here), like so: M’I-STYE-YE’D.

  1. Project frustrated carrot producer may finally get? (5,3)

Answer: STICK OUT (i.e. to “project”). The remainder of the clue plays on the phrase “carrot and stick” being forms of encouragement and punishment. The inference here is that the carrot has had no effect, so it’s time to get the STICK OUT.

  1. Mark of separation, after shrinking, that remains (5)

Answer: THETA. 100% guess here, so watch out. I’m going for this being a symbol or “mark” that is used for a wide variety of purposes. Chambers offers this is a “mark of condemnation” or death, which I suppose you could equate to “mark of separation” if you really squint your eyes. You could also weakly argue that the letters of THETA, after the E has been removed, the word having been “shrunk”, gets you the letters of “that”. I’m not really buying it, though, as such indicators are used to trim end letters from a word, not those in the middle. If someone swings by with a better solution then I’ll update the post.

[EDIT: Scratch that, the solution is TREMA, “a diaresis, two dots placed as a mark of separate pronunciation over a vowel letter” (Chambers). My Oxford comes up dry on this one, which is a rarity. “After shrinking” indicates the solution has been hidden in the clue, like so: THA(T REMA)INS. Thanks to Chris and Sue in the comments for coming to the rescue! – LP]

  1. Be capable of being heard in any conditions (5)

Answer: NOHOW (i.e. “in any conditions” – my Chambers and Oxford would disagree, stating the exact opposite of this, being “a negative” or “under no circumstances”. Hard to see what the setter had in mind here. Maybe everything good in their world is “bad”, “sick” or (especially up north) “hellish”). “Being heard” indicates the solution is a homophone of KNOW HOW (i.e. “be capable of”).

  1. No good being upset (4)

Answer: EVIL (i.e. “no good”). Solution is LIVE (i.e. “being”) reversed (indicated by “upset” – this being a down clue).

  1. Singular record becoming big hit (4)

Answer: SLOG (i.e. “big hit”). Solution is S (a recognised abbreviation of “singular”) followed by LOG (i.e. “record”).

19 thoughts on “Times Jumbo Cryptic Crossword 1598

  1. Hi Lucian. Stinker indeed. After several hours of sweating blood we ended up with a letter in every space, but in several cases had no idea why. So thanks, as always, for your explanations.

    22a: I think the final E can be explained by CARAVANSERAI being defined as E(astern) INN. A bit convoluted, I agree, but it’s the best we could come up with.

    48d: Not THETA (which was our first thought too) but TREMA (no, me neither). A trema is apparently a kind of diaresis – a mark placed over the second of two adjacent vowels to indicate that they should be sounded separately (eg naïve). The answer is hidden in the clue: “… after shrinking thaT REMAins”.

    Hope this helps. Take care, and stay safe. SB

    1. Wow yes, tough. Some great clues and not too many quibbles. Despite others’ suggestions I am still not happy with some of the parsings:
      • In 41a, ‘s’ just isn’t an accepted abbreviation of ‘suffers’. So I side with Lucian on that one – ‘stands’ + ‘am’.
      • In 22a, the ‘e’ can’t represent ‘eastern’ because that word is not within the clue. But could it be the ‘℮’ symbol (Unicode: 212E) on EU-origin packaged goods, which represents ‘estimated’ or within tolerances, hence ‘possible’? (See Wikipedia). That’s my best shot: I have nothing better to offer.
      My larger problem with 22a is with the definition of “set” for a transistor radio. Back in the dark ages, before the 1950s were out, for my tenth birthday I was given one of the very first trannies, a micro-miracle of about 7 x 5 x 4 inches. Tinny loudspeaker, but this Japanese marvel was completely unlike any known ‘wireless set’. Thanks to its batteries you could take it on a bike to a picnic, on the beach, in the playground, down the bottom of your bed after lights out. Who ever listened to Radio Caroline on a ‘set’? I rest my case, m’lud.
      Lucian, the Elder Gods were pacified this week because legerdemain is three French words all wrapped in one.

  2. Thanks, Lucian. A toughie indeed! Re 36d I think the bases which are cut are feet, not fees. Re 48d I think it’s trema which is another word for diaeresis which is a mark to indicate two vowels are pronounced separately. The word Trena is contained inside that remains. Cheers

  3. Hi Lucien. I think stand in 41a refers to buy drinks for everyone, as in “stand a drink”, followed by as for suffers and am for morning

  4. Oof, a stinker and a half. For the first time in a very very long time I failed to finish a Jumbo – Sfax and Trema defeated me, so thanks for the explanation, and the parsing of VALENTINE. Thought I was doing well to find ‘Stand sam’ and ‘Cockneyfy’ which are both in Chambers, but those last two were out of reach.

    1. Unlike Lucian I’m not so bothered about COCKNEYFY being in the dictionary – but ‘suit to’ for ‘suit’??? How is that possible? Or am I missing something?

      1. I think it’s because ‘cocknefy’ ’ does not mean ‘suit Eastenders’. Rather it means ‘make to suit Eastenders’ or simply ‘to suit Eastenders’. Cheers

  5. Well, I’m ashamed to say I gave up (the distractions of Arsenal, then Wales and then England lose is a feeble but not irrelevant factor)
    Well done Chris and Sue and of course Lucian
    There’s no excuse for muck like dropping in the irrelevant 2021 in 23d. I wondered if 23d whether cut above isn’t re a haircut, but a laughable notion that Etonians are better than the rest of us. Cheers Graham

  6. Yes, we felt exactly the same way. A grim satisfaction in trudging all the way through to the end rather than a fun activity.
    About Eton Crop – my dictionary describes this as a “short mannish hairstyle worn by women in the 1920’s” so I think the crop of 2021 is code for 1920-1921.
    Sue, Chris and others beat me to the clarification of Eastern Inn and Feet. And we got Jocose wrong, so thank you for setting us straight on that.
    By the way, didn’t you spot a tinge of Frenchness in Leger de Main???

  7. Thanks Lucian,
    I didn’t complete this so many thanks for clearing up the loose ends.
    Re 56a. Legerdemain. Is this really a homophone? Do people really pronounce it ‘ledger domaine’? If so, it’s a whole new level of mangling of the French language.

  8. A defeat for me as well. Four left around “entrance fee”. More pain that pleasure this week, obscure clues to obscure words, congrats to all those who succeeded.

  9. Re jumbo cryptic 1598: 48d
    Mark of separation, after shrinking, that remains.
    Could be TREMA, an included word; trema meaning, apparently, Greek for hole. Still not totally convinced, but this puzzle was full of horrendous clues and awkward parsing.
    So pleased to have found your site recently. We hate getting an answer but not being able to work out why! Thanks so much.
    Helen and Hugh Mathew.

    Sent from my iPhone

  10. I am very late to the party here as I have been in La belle France this last week. The irony of a largely Frenchless puzzle is not lost on me.
    We really did not like this one. Whilst a more challenging puzzle is fine, I found the clues without a separate definition ( ie where the whole clue pointed vaguely towards it) rather irritating. Ralph , my co-solver, did not like the syntax of many of the clues , which I agree did not flow well. Some clever ideas in there, but too much was awkward and not particularly robust.
    C’est la vie!

  11. Well Mrs Mac and I finished this and I have never had so many ‘ugh’s and ‘hm’s comments littered across the completed clues. Stinker indeed.
    I could pick many to comment on but I will note the irony of one of the clues – in this nearly zero French By Volume crossword – relying on a *very* Anglicised (and IMO horrible) pronunciation of legerdemain! Ugh.

  12. We were early to this crossword and after 3 days, my 93 year old father and me (a relatively newbie to cryptics) not only tossed it into the naughty corner and then directly into recycling with only 4 clues done. It was a bad start to a rather busy week.

    Anyway, nice to see some more members of the Lucien fan club commenting.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.